Tag: fiscal policy

  • IMF’s fiscal strategy for Pakistan criticised for overlooking debt restructuring

    IMF’s fiscal strategy for Pakistan criticised for overlooking debt restructuring

    The International Monetary Fund (IMF)’s current fiscal strategy for Pakistan, which focuses on strict fiscal consolidation—entailing reduced spending and increased revenue—has come under significant scrutiny.

    Critics, including Murtaza Syed, a former deputy governor of the State Bank of Pakistan and ex-IMF official, question the approach due to its lack of emphasis on debt restructuring.

    In his article “Debt Will Tear Us Apart (Again)”, Syed highlights the IMF’s omission of debt sustainability in recent discussions.

     Despite Pakistan securing a staff-level agreement with the IMF for the 24th time, this absence is surprising given the IMF’s near-declaration of Pakistan’s debt as unsustainable in May. Syed suggests that both Pakistan and the IMF might be shying away from a transparent evaluation of the debt burden.

    Syed warns that the current “extend and pretend” strategy could lead to severe repercussions. He argues that it will impose harsh austerity measures on a population already burdened by stagnant income, a historic cost of living crisis, and political instability.

    This approach may result in deeper losses for creditors and further damage the IMF’s reputation.

    The article provides stark figures illustrating Pakistan’s debt crisis. The country owes an average of $19 billion in principal repayments annually, which exceeds half of its export revenues.

    Additionally, Pakistan will require at least $6 billion per year to cover its current account deficit, bringing its total external financing needs to around $25 billion annually until 2029.

    Moreover, the government will need to allocate an average of 6.5 per cent of GDP for interest payments on existing debt over the next five years.

    Syed criticises the IMF’s optimistic forecasts for Pakistan’s economic variables, noting that previous predictions have often been unrealistic. He argues that fiscal consolidations, particularly in a weak global environment, tend to fail in making debt more sustainable.

    In his conclusion, Syed calls for a shift from harsh fiscal measures to a more balanced approach that includes debt restructuring, to reduce financial pressures and support economic development.

  • Suzuki Swift GLX CVT now priced above Rs5.4 million

    Suzuki Swift GLX CVT now priced above Rs5.4 million

    Pak Suzuki Motor Company Limited (PSMC) announced a substantial increase of Rs304,000 in the price of its Swift G. CVT model, effective from March 8, 2024.

    This adjustment comes in response to the recent surge in taxes imposed by the government on locally manufactured or assembled vehicles, as indicated in the company’s official notice issued today.

    Consequently, the new sale price for the Swift G. CVT model will see an adjustment from Rs5.125 million to Rs5.429 million, reflecting the impact of the revised tax structure.

    The decision stems from a notification released by the Ministry of Finance and Revenue on the same date, highlighting a hike in the sales tax rate from 18 per cent to 25 per cent for vehicles falling under chapter 87.03 of the Pakistan Custom Tariffs, with an invoice price (excluding sales tax) exceeding Rs4 million.

  • Pakistan may enter fresh IMF loan programme, stricter conditions expected

    Pakistan may enter fresh IMF loan programme, stricter conditions expected

    In the wake of the completion of its current loan programme, Pakistan is poised to sign a new loan agreement with the International Monetary Fund (IMF), reports indicate. 

    The forthcoming Extended Fund Facility programme, anticipated to span three years, will see Islamabad share budget proposals for FY 2024–25 with the IMF. 

    Sources suggest that before finalising the agreement, Pakistan will provide assurances to the IMF regarding further increases in electricity and gas prices, as well as a commitment to reduce subsidies. 

    Finance ministry sources have disclosed that the conditions for the new loan programme are expected to be more stringent compared to the current Standby Agreement (SBA) programme. 

    Earlier discussions hinted at Pakistan securing another loan package from the IMF following the conclusion of the ongoing standby agreement. 

    The caretaker government has commenced consultations for the upcoming IMF programme, with talks expected to commence this month. 

    Officials from the finance ministry have indicated that the measures initiated by the caretaker government will be continued by the elected government in discussions with the IMF.

  • OGRA approves massive gas tariff hike for SNGPL, SSGC consumers

    OGRA approves massive gas tariff hike for SNGPL, SSGC consumers

    In a move to address the fiscal challenges faced by Sui Northern Gas Pipelines Limited (SNGPL) and Sui Southern Gas Company Limited (SSGC), the Oil and Gas Regulatory Authority (OGRA) has granted approval for a noteworthy increase in gas tariffs.

    Effective January 1, 2024, consumers of SNGPL will experience a 35.13 per cent surge, while SSGC customers will witness an 8.57 per cent rise.

    This marks the second adjustment in gas prices within the current fiscal year, following a substantial 193 per cent increase announced by OGRA, effective November 1, 2023. The decision to implement these changes is aimed at bridging the Rs98 billion shortfall collectively faced by both gas companies.

    The interim government’s initial projections aimed to collect Rs980 billion, intending to cover the estimated revenue requirements of Rs700 billion for both SNGPL and SSGC.

    The recommended average increase in the prescribed gas price is set at 23 per cent, reaching Rs1,590 per mmbtu, compared to the previous average of Rs1,291 per mmbtu determined on June 2, 2023.

    Specifically, OGRA has outlined a 50 per cent increase (Rs415.11 per mmbtu) for SNGPL, elevating the gas price to Rs1,238.68 per mmbtu, effective July 1, 2023.

    Simultaneously, the gas price for SSGC has been raised by 45 per cent (Rs417.23 per mmbtu) to reach Rs1,350.68 per mmbtu.

    The decision to increase gas prices aligns with the interim government’s commitment to the International Monetary Fund (IMF), with an agreement to announce a raise in gas sale prices by February 18, 2024.

    However, the OGRA Ordinance stipulates that if the government remains unresponsive to OGRA’s notification within 40 days, the determined tariff by the regulator will be automatically enforced.

    The recent approval underscores the ongoing efforts to address financial challenges and ensure the sustainability of the gas sector in Pakistan.

  • SBP receives second IMF installment, total disbursements reach $1.9 billion

    SBP receives second IMF installment, total disbursements reach $1.9 billion

    The State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) announced today that it has successfully received the second installment of SDR 528 million, equivalent to $705.6 million, from the International Monetary Fund (IMF).

    This disbursement, slated to be reflected in SBP reserves for the week ending on January 19, 2024, marks a significant step in the ongoing financial collaboration between Pakistan and the IMF.

    The latest disbursement brings the total disbursements under the stand-by arrangement (SBA) to a substantial $1.9 billion.

    It is noteworthy that the remaining $1.1 billion is expected to be received after another comprehensive review scheduled for February 2024.

    As of January 5, 2024, the State Bank of Pakistan’s total reserves stand at $8.15 billion, showcasing the positive impact of the financial support received through the IMF programme.

    To recall, Pakistan secured a $3 billion SBA from the IMF towards the end of FY23, crucially preventing the nation from defaulting on its sovereign debt.

    The disbursement of the IMF funds has been phased out over two installments, subject to meticulous reviews.

    On January 11, 2024, Pakistan successfully completed the first review of the economic reform programme, a significant milestone in ensuring the country’s financial stability.

    Following the board’s approval, the IMF highlighted that economic activity has stabilised, though acknowledging that the outlook remains challenging and is contingent on the implementation of sound policies.

    Pakistan’s 9-month SBA aims to provide a robust policy anchor for addressing both domestic and external balances, serving as a framework for continued financial support from multilateral and bilateral partners.

    This financial collaboration with the IMF is instrumental in navigating Pakistan through economic challenges, providing a solid foundation for sustained growth and stability in the region.

    The country remains committed to implementing prudent economic policies as outlined in the reform programme, with the ongoing support of international partners.

  • IMF and Pakistan seal agreement on $3 billion SBA, await board approval

    IMF and Pakistan seal agreement on $3 billion SBA, await board approval

    In a significant development, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) declared on Wednesday that its team and Pakistani authorities have successfully concluded the initial review of the $3 billion, nine-month Stand-By Arrangement (SBA).

    This staff-level agreement awaits the approval of the IMF Executive Board.

    Upon endorsement, approximately US$700 million (SDR 528 million) will be accessible, contributing to a cumulative disbursement of nearly US$1.9 billion under the programme.

    A delegation from the IMF, led by Nathan Porter, conducted discussions in Islamabad from November 2–15, 2023, focusing on the inaugural review of Pakistan’s economic programme supported by the IMF SBA.

    The nascent recovery, supported by international partners and enhanced confidence indicators, is attributed to the stabilizing policies outlined in the SBA.

    The disciplined implementation of the FY24 budget, ongoing adjustments in energy prices, and increased inflows into the foreign exchange (FX) market have alleviated fiscal and external pressures.

    The IMF anticipates a decline in inflation in the upcoming months, driven by diminishing supply constraints and modest demand.

    Nevertheless, Pakistan remains exposed to significant external risks, including heightened geopolitical tensions, escalating commodity prices, and potential tightening in global financial conditions.

    It is imperative to persist in efforts to enhance resilience in the face of these challenges, according to the international lender

  • Pakistan’s imports drop sharply, leading to 42% reduction in trade deficit

    Pakistan’s imports drop sharply, leading to 42% reduction in trade deficit

    Pakistan’s trade deficit for the first three months of the fiscal year 2023–24 has notably contracted by 42.25 per cent to reach $5.29 billion. This remarkable reduction is primarily attributed to a significant decrease in imports, a direct consequence of carefully administered measures.

    Data released by the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS) reveals that the trade balance, which represents the difference between exports and imports, stood at a deficit of $5.29 billion for the period spanning July to September 2023–24. This is in stark contrast to the $9.16 billion deficit recorded during the same period in the preceding year.

    Both exports and imports experienced declines in this timeframe, with imports showing a more substantial decrease compared to exports, effectively narrowing the trade deficit. During these three months of 2023–24, Pakistan’s exports contracted by 3.8 per cent to $6.9 billion, despite facing significant currency depreciation when compared to the corresponding period in the previous year.

    Conversely, imports registered a notable decline of 25.4 per cent, totaling $12.19 billion in the July–September period, down from the $16.33 billion recorded in the same period of the previous fiscal year.

    For a more granular view, the PBS reported that in September 2023, Pakistan’s trade deficit further shrank by nearly 48 per cent to $1.489 billion, compared to $2.856 billion during the same month in the previous year. 

    Exports experienced a slight improvement of 1.1 per cent, reaching $2.47 billion in September 2023 compared to $2.44 billion in the same month the previous year, while imports significantly decreased by 25.5 per cent to $3.95 billion from $5.29 billion in the corresponding month last year.

    From a monthly perspective, the trade deficit contracted by 31.5 per cent compared to August 2023, with exports increasing by 4.2 per cent to $2.47 billion in September from $2.37 billion in the preceding month of August. Simultaneously, imports decreased by 12.9 per cent, amounting to $3.95 billion from $4.53 billion in the last month.

  • Govt’s borrowing soars to over Rs1.6 trillion in three months, marking a fivefold increase from last year

    Govt’s borrowing soars to over Rs1.6 trillion in three months, marking a fivefold increase from last year

    In the current fiscal year, FY24, the federal government’s net borrowing to meet its financial obligations for governing the nation amounted to Rs1.6 trillion.

    According to official data released by the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP), the government secured loans exceeding Rs1.6 trillion in cash from the domestic banking sector during the first quarter, up significantly from the Rs261 billion borrowed during the same period in the previous year.

    During this period, the government obtained a net loan of Rs98 billion from SBP. It’s worth noting that the government is obligated to adhere to International Monetary Fund regulations, which prohibit direct borrowing from the central bank.

    Additionally, the government raised Rs1.5 trillion from scheduled banks in the first quarter of FY24 (up to September 8) to address the budget deficit.

    The net borrowing by the government for budgetary support in FY23 totaled Rs3.74 trillion, marking an increase from Rs3.13 trillion in FY22.

  • PDM govt adds Rs18.5 trillion to Pakistan’s debt in just 15 months

    PDM govt adds Rs18.5 trillion to Pakistan’s debt in just 15 months

    In a span of just 15 months, the Pakistan Democratic Movement (PDM) government has significantly added Rs18.5 trillion to the country’s public debt, a striking amount surpassing the debt accumulation of its rival, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), during its three-and-a-half-year tenure.

    Between March 2022 and the close of the 2022–23 fiscal year, the gross public debt surged from Rs44.4 trillion to Rs62.9 trillion. This rapid increase of 41.7 per cent in just 15 months occurred without a well-defined strategy to curb it. As a result, the federal government’s debt, for which the finance ministry bears direct responsibility, escalated to Rs60.8 trillion by June 2023. The debt bulletin, published on a recent Wednesday, indicates an addition of Rs18 trillion during the PDM government’s one year and three months in power.

    As per a report in the Express Tribune by Shehbaz Rana, this unsustainable surge in public debt is mainly ascribed to unregulated spending, insufficient revenue collection from areas such as real estate, services, and agriculture, alongside the diminishing value of the Pakistani rupee in comparison to the US dollar.

    It’s worth noting that the government under Imran Khan added Rs18.1 trillion to the public debt over a span of 44 months, a threshold that the current administration led by Shehbaz Sharif managed to surpass in just 15 months. However, it’s important to mention that the debt figure for July has yet to be compiled by the State Bank of Pakistan.

    This trend becomes even more significant when we consider that the combined debt addition by the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) and the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) from 2008 to 2018 was Rs18 trillion. Another Rs18 trillion was added from August 2018 to March 2022 during Imran Khan’s government, and now the PDM government has contributed an additional Rs18.5 trillion in a remarkably brief period of 15 months.

    Comparatively, from September 1, 2018, to the end of March 2022, the PTI government, on average, increased the public debt by Rs14.5 billion per day, more than double the average daily increase of Rs5.6 billion during the PML-N period. The PDM government has further escalated this daily addition to an average of Rs41 billion.

    By the time the PTI government’s term concluded, the total public debt amounted to Rs44.4 trillion, equivalent to 83.5 per cent of the gross domestic product (GDP) before the economy’s rebasing. Following the rebasing process, there was a 15 per cent reduction in public debt relative to GDP but no reduction in absolute terms.

    At present, the public debt constitutes 74.3 per cent of the GDP. Steep currency depreciation has also contributed to the federal government’s debt. Over the past 15 months, the total domestic debt of the federal government surged to Rs38.8 trillion, an addition of Rs10.8 trillion (or 38 per cent). When Imran Khan left office, the domestic debt stood at Rs28 trillion.

    Alarmingly, the external debt of the federal government surged by 48 per cent to Rs22 trillion within just 15 months, with a net increase of Rs7.1 trillion attributed largely to currency depreciation. By the end of March 2022, the external debt, excluding IMF liabilities, was Rs14.9 trillion.

    External debt constitutes roughly 36 per cent of the total debt, and fluctuations in the exchange rate have a significant impact on debt even without borrowing additional funds. In a span of 15 months, the rupee-dollar parity plummeted from Rs183.5 to Rs286.4, a decline of Rs103 or 56 per cent. This substantial and rapid depreciation has also contributed to inflation.

    On a recent Wednesday, the rupee slid further to Rs295. An immediate outcome of this mounting debt is a considerable rise in the cost of debt servicing. It is projected that debt servicing will exceed Rs5.8 trillion by the end of the last fiscal year. 

    As a result of reckless borrowing, Pakistan’s total debt and liabilities have surged to Rs77.1 trillion, equivalent to 91.1 per cent of the national economy’s size. This ratio is deemed unsustainable for a developing nation like Pakistan.

    During the past four years of the IMF programme, Pakistan struggled to enhance the Federal Board of Revenue’s (FBR) tax-to-GDP ratio, despite it being a priority for both the IMF and the World Bank.

    This raises concerns about the effectiveness of obtaining foreign loans for the sake of tax reform. Moreover, there has been a lack of serious efforts to control expenditures. The Shehbaz Sharif government, like its predecessors, continued to allocate funds to projects and initiatives that fall under provincial jurisdiction as per the constitution.